-
Financial administration & outsourcing
Entrepreneurs who outsource financial administration reduce the number of administrative tasks and consequently have more time and space to focus on growth.
-
Financial insight
We help you turn financial data into valuable insights that support you in making well-founded decisions. In-depth analyses of your financial situation will help give you a better idea of where you stand and where the opportunities for growth lie, both in the short and long term.
-
Financial compliance
We make sure your company complies with financial legislation and regulations, with correct financial statements, tax reports and other obligations. From our global network, we support you in managing local and international tax risks.
-
Impact House by Grant Thornton
Building sustainability and social impact. That sounds good. But how do you go about it in the complex world of stakeholders, regulations and frameworks and changing demands from clients and society? How do you deal with important issues such as climate change and biodiversity loss?
-
Business risk services
Minimize risk, maximize predictability, and execution Good insights help you look further ahead and adapt faster. Whether you require outsourced or co-procured internal audit services and expertise to address a specific technology, cyber or regulatory challenge, we provide a turnkey and reliable solution.
-
Cyber risk services
What should I be doing first if my data has been kidnapped? Have I taken the right precautions for protecting my data or am I putting too much effort into just one of the risks? And how do I quickly detect intruders on my network? Good questions! We help you to answer these questions.
-
Deal advisory
What will the net proceeds be after the sale? How do I optimise the selling price of my business or the price of one of my business activities?
-
Forensic & integrity services
Do you require a fact finding investigation to help assess irregularities? Is it necessary to ascertain facts for litigation purposes?
-
Valuations
Independent and objective valuations tailored for mergers, acquisitions, and legal matters.
-
Auditing of annual accounts
You are answerable to others, such as shareholders and other stakeholders, with regard to your financial affairs. Financial information must therefore be reliable. What is more, you want to know how far you are progressing towards achieving your goals and what risks may apply.
-
IFRS services
Financial reporting in accordance with IFRS is a complex matter. Nowadays, an increasing number of international companies are becoming aware of the rules. But how do you apply them in practice?
-
ISAE & SOC Reporting
Our ISAE & SOC Reporting services provide independent and objective reports on the design, implementation and operational effectiveness of controls at service organizations.
-
National tax advice
Looking for tax advice in the Netherlands? We help business owners with tailor-made tax advice: from structure and compliance to innovation and sustainability.
-
International tax advice
Plan to do business abroad? Our international tax advice helps you with structure and compliance, as well as offering new opportunities. Strategic, practical, and future-oriented.
-
Private wealth services
Our Private Wealth specialists offer strategic and practical solutions. From tax advice to estate planning and financial scenarios, we make sure you make the right choices today, for tomorrow.
-
Corporate Law
From the general terms and conditions to the legal strategy, these matters need to be watertight. This provides assurance, and therefore peace of mind and room for growth. We will be pro-active and pragmatic in thinking along with you. We always like to look ahead and go the extra mile.
-
Employment Law
What obligations do you have with an employee on sick leave? How do you go about a reorganisation? As an entrepreneur, you want clear answers and practical solutions to your employment law questions. At Grant Thornton, we are there for you with clear advice, from contracts and terms of employment to complex matters such as dismissal or reorganisation.
-
Sustainable legal
At Grant Thornton, we help companies integrate sustainability into their business operations, with sustainable legal at the heart of our approach. We advise on ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) legislation, and help draft sustainable contracts, implement HR policies, and carry out ESG due diligence in M&A transactions (Mergers and Acquisitions).
-
HR Services
HR is not an aspect of secondary relevance, rather a strategic factor for success. Yet many organisations struggle with issues regarding personnel policy, absenteeism, terms of employment and legislation and regulations.
-
Payroll & wage tax
Payment of salaries is not a simple calculation. Laws and regulations constantly change, and mistakes can quickly cause employees to be dissatisfied or lead to tax risks.
-
Compensation and benefits
The labour market is changing rapidly. Employees want flexibility, a sense of purpose and a good mixture of financial and non-financial benefits.
-
Pension advisory services
Pension is more than an obligation. It is a strategic term of employment that touches upon your employer brand, financial scope and responsibility to provide for your employees.
-
Global mobility services
How can you build and evolve a smart global mobility strategy, with policies and processes addressing the complex challenges of managing an international workforce?

The CJEU has previously already addressed the question whether a subsidiary (or other legally independent entity) can constitute an FE of another company. For example, in its judgement in the case C-333/20 (Berlin Chemie), it stated that a legally independent entity belonging to the same group may create an FE for an affiliated company when it can dispose of the former entity's resources as if they were its own.
The main difference between the current Cabot Plastics and the previous Berlin Chemie case is that in the current case, the service provider belonging to the same group does not only provide sales’ support services to its principal but also toll manufacturing services. In its judgment of Cabot Plastics, the CJEU largely follows its judgment in Berlin Chemie and states that the toll manufacturing and ancillary logistical and sales’ support services do not create an FE for a receiving company, even if they are provided under an exclusive basis.
Facts
A Swiss company Cabot Switzerland GmbH (Cabot CH) concluded a tolling contract with a legally independent Belgian company Cabot Plastics (Cabot BE) belonging to the same group. Final products were sold by Cabot CH from Belgium to various customers on the Belgian market, on the EU market or for export.
Next to the toll manufacturing, Cabot BE also provided a series of additional services under the exclusive agreement with Cabot CH, in particular, storage of its products, making recommendations and providing support regarding the manufacturing process, facilitating customs formalities, providing compliance with various standards as well as customs and excise duties.
The Belgian tax authority came to the conclusion that Cabot CH had an FE in Belgium for the purposes of the VAT and that, accordingly, the services provided by Cabot BE to that company between 2014 and 2016 had to be regarded as taking place in Belgium and subject to VAT in Belgium.
Questions referred to the CJEU
The referring court found that the CJEU had not yet ruled on a case sufficiently similar to the present one, capable of dispelling any doubts as to the interpretation to be given to the applicable EU law. It noted, in that respect, first, that Cabot BE is a legally separate entity from Cabot CH, and second, that the tax authority regards Cabot BE both as a service provider and as constituting the technical and human resources of Cabot CH in Belgium. Therefore, it raised the question of whether Cabot CH has a suitable structure, in terms of its own resources, constituting its FE in Belgium, where those resources belong to Cabot BE providing services to it, but in accordance with a contract concluded between Cabot CH and Cabot BE, the latter undertakes to use those resources, exclusively or almost exclusively, to provide those services.
The referring court also questions the effect which the supply of goods by Cabot CH in Belgium, using technical and human resources of Cabot BE, could have on identifying an FE of Cabot CH in that country.
The issue is whether an FE is created for Cabot CH in Belgium by its service provider if the latter supplies it, in agreement with an exclusive contractual undertaking, not only toll manufacturing but also a series of ancillary services, thus contributing to the completion of sales of goods by Cabot CH in Belgium?
Decision
FE requires a suitable structure to enable receiving the services
The CJEU referred to its previous decision in case Welmory (C-605/12) by stating that to be considered as having an FE in another country, it must have a sufficiently permanent and suitable structure in that country to enable it to receive the services concerned there and to use them for its business.
Furthermore, the CJEU referred to its earlier decision in C-333/20 (Berlin Chemie) by stating that:
- Although a subsidiary/separate legal entity can create an FE for a company belonging to the same group, the fact that a company has a subsidiary in another country does not, in itself, mean that it also has its FE there.
- The disposal of resources as if they were its own is required for an FE to be created.
- An exclusive contract does not mean that an FE is created.
- Even if an FE is created because of sales of goods, this does not mean that services are received by the same FE.
- Preparatory or auxiliary activities do not create an FE for the receiving company.
- Services cannot be both supplied and received by the same FE.
The CJEU concluded that a business does not have an FE as a result of receiving services from an affiliated company, where that recipient does not have a suitable structure in terms of human and technical resources capable of constituting that FE.
Consequences for practice
This decision is also important for other sectors than toll manufacturing and provides further clarity for internationally operating companies.
Although, in the Netherlands, the staff and technical means of a legally independent (affiliated) entity are generally not considered to constitute an FE of another entity, the issue has caused a lot of controversy in several other countries, such as Belgium and Poland. After this decision, the tax authorities of the latter countries have less room to argue that a service provider in the EU country can create an FE for its affiliated entity who sells its goods in this country. Therefore, the case is very welcome for businesses operating internationally, as it provides more clarity on the interpretation of concept of FE and offers guidance and support in discussions with tax authorities.
The existence of an FE is very relevant for B2C supplies, but also for B2B services (e.g. in place of supply issues, the applicability of the reverse charge) or even supply of goods (e.g. the applicability of the EU call-off stock simplification).
Do you have any questions or do you want to discuss your situation?